Bankruptcy and Indubitable Equivalent Value—When Is a Prior Value Determination or Stipulated Value Not the Value of the Business?
A forensic accountant, litigation consultant or a business valuation expert is often tasked with the prospect of “interpreting” clauses in an agreement from a financial point of view without expressing a legal opinion. In addition, the expert may be required to then determine the financial consequences of that interpretation. Those results are often the subject of controversy when adversarial positions are posited by competing experts or when challenged in a court of law.
One aspect of the dispute, and one with significant consequences, centered around the term indubitable equivalent value for a Class 5 creditor in the context of Debtor’s Fifth Amended Chapter 11 Plan and objection to confirmation filed by Creditor. The United States Bankruptcy Court, Middle District of Florida, Jacksonville Division (the “Court”) opined on that issue (Spiderman Scott Mulholland and Tina Marie Foley Mulholland Debtors, Case No. 3:18-bk-04096-JAF, Chapter 11, January 14, 2022).
By way of background, in 2018, Debtors (husband and wife) filed a voluntary petition for bankruptcy under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code. The Creditor had filed a secured proof of claim pursuant to a state-court judgment in 2018 against the Debtors. The judgment against Debtors was over $4.6 million and increased to $5.1 million in 2020 with post-judgment interest.
The bankruptcy estate included 100% of the stock in an operating entity that provided remediation construction services. Debtor husband was the owner, key person and “rainmaker” as well as influencer for the business. The Creditor, the daughter of the Debtors, was in her mid-30’s with no business experience and no involvement in the company.
In July 2019, pursuant to a Court Order, Creditor’s claim was fully secured by all non-exempt assets and the stock in the business. The Debtors’ stock in the business pursuant to a consent order and agreed to by the parties was valued at a minimum of $4.8 million. The Court further stated that the Debtors’ business was valued no less than $4.8 million.
In this connection, Debtor husband was to turn over his 100% equity interest in the business as payment on Creditor’s claim. The position of Counsel for the Debtors was that the value shall never be determined again since it was “agreed” upon and stipulated and therefore not subject to be relitigated. Counsel for Debtors advocated for confirmation of the modified plan under 11 U.S.C. Section 1129(b)(1) that the plan was fair and equitable under Section 1129(b)(2)(A) and provided for fair and equitable treatment.
Creditor’s counsel’s position was that Debtors’ proposed treatment was not fair and equitable and that the turnover of stock to the Creditor was conditional in that the Debtors would remain employed in the business and receive dictated salaries. Counsel requested that the Court allow expert testimony that would demonstrate that the value of the business would be negatively impacted since the proposed plan did not provide for the continued employment of the Debtors nor provide for a non-compete agreement post-turnover of the stock.
According to Section 1129(b)(2)(A), three conditions must be met. (I) the creditor keeps all liens and receives payments equal to the present value of the creditor’s interest in estate property; (ii) if there is a sale of the collateral, the creditor retains liens on the proceeds from the sale and receives payment equal to the creditor’s interest in such proceeds; or (iii) the creditor receives the “indubitable equivalent” of its claims.
The Court, in its decision, agreed with the Creditor’s position that the plan does not meet condition a) that hinged on an indefinite delay to sell the business due to extraneous circumstances nor condition ii) since the plan restricts the Creditor’s right to “credit bid in any amount less than the full amount of her remaining allowed claim”.
The third condition is for the realization of the indubitable equivalent of its claims. Counsel for the creditor insisted that the prior Court Order for the value of the business would not be available to the secured creditor and invited valuation evidence as appropriate to determine the fair and equitable nature of a proposed cram down.
There are numerous cases where the issue of indubitable equivalent was addressed. See for example, In re SUD Properties, Inc., Case No. 11-03833-8-RDD (Bankr. E.D.N.C. Aug. 23, 2011, for collateral for real estate lots under a mortgage where “dirt for debt” proposals are fair and equitable to secured creditors, as valuation issues can be heavily debated and where the debtor carries a stiff burden of proof to demonstrate that the value of the property offered will yield enough cash to reach the level of the indubitable equivalent of the secured creditor’s claim.
Also, In re San Felipe@Voss Ltd., 115 B.R. 526,529 (S.D. Tex.1990 , when a plan was confirmed for a payment package where the substituted security was compensatory and the likelihood that the secured creditor would be paid. In Re Future Energy Corp, 83 B.R. 470, 496 (Bankr. S.D. Ohio 1988), where the confirmation of a plan was denied by the court for a proposal to substitute securities for collateral due to the questionable value of stock with no established market.
In the case discussed in this article, the Court stated “Ultimately, “to qualify as the ‘indubitable equivalent’ of its claim, ‘the treatment must be completely compensatory”’ and there must be “no reasonable doubt the creditor will be paid in full.”
The question for the Court to determine was whether the turnover of the company by the Debtor (father of the Creditor) to the Creditor (daughter of Debtor), combined with deferred cash payments, constitutes realization of the “indubitable equivalent” of Creditor’s claim.
Additional testimony was provided to address the prior Order for the “minimum value”. Testimony was provided from a practitioner’s point of view on the undefined term indubitable equivalent on or about the date of confirmation in the context of the present actual business circumstances and likely impairment of the stipulated value based upon facts and circumstances.
The Court focused on several cases as an instructive opinion. In RE Sugarleaf Timber, LLC, 529 B.R. at 325-26.This case involved land financed by creditor Farm Credit. Sugarleaf defaulted. The property was secured by various mortgages and liens. Although Farm Credit rejected the plan and objected to the confirmation, the bankruptcy court determined the value of the property, net of sell commissions, exceeded the secured claim and provided a cushion. As such, the court concluded that the turnover provided the creditor with the indubitable equivalent of its claim and confirmed the proposed Chapter 11 plan. Farm Credit appealed.
The district court stated, “to qualify as the ‘indubitable equivalent’ of its claim, ‘the treatment must be completely compensatory’” and there must be “no reasonable doubt [ ] the creditor will be paid in full.” Since there was an equity cushion and since the property could readily be sold, this ensured Farm Credit that it would receive the indubitable equivalent of its claim.
The Court articulated certain key points in addition to others. These included the fact that there was no potential buyer and no clear path to sell the business to a third party and the Debtor’s proposal of an indefinite timeline to sell the business that was contingent on other matters.
Furthermore, even with a potential buyer, “it is extremely doubtful that Trahan (“Creditor and daughter”) would receive $4.8 million due to the lack of a noncompete agreement with Spiderman Mulholland (“Debtor and father”) or any other employee.” The Court recognized that the Debtor husband was the main driver of revenue for the business as he had the requisite technical skill set to attract customers and was responsible for developing the book of clients and resultant goodwill of the business that were key assets of the business.
“Spiderman Mulholland was the face of the business and effectively controls US Building’s book of clients.” Their absence would likely result in a precipitous drop in revenue simply because of Debtor husband leaving the business to a competitor and taking clients with him.
Since the Creditor did not have the requisite skill set, training or experience to manage the business nor the ability to retain key employees and clients to protect her own self-interest and create a “managerial minefield for the company” that would “torpedo” the estate’s primary asset.
From the above commentary, it was reasonably ascertainable and apparent that the minimum value as previously established at $4.8 million for the business, represented value only with the Debtors continuing to operate the business in the same manner as it had been operated in the past with Debtor husband at the helm. Practitioner valued the business on or about the date of confirmation at a significantly lower threshold in the absence of having measures in place to potentially negate the issues regarding the proposed transfer of the business as discussed herein. It is evident that the Proposed Plan must consider these issues from the Creditor’s position and their ability to receive the “indubitable equivalent” value.
The Court concluded that the plan does not provide for the “indubitable equivalent” of Creditor’s claim. The Court stated that it was “the Debtors’ intent to use this Case as a means of pausing Trahan’s collection efforts, without proposing a confirmable plan, …” and found that there was cause to dismiss the case.
Accordingly, consideration of all relevant factors that affect and impact the valuation of a business must be addressed and considered in the context of determining the indubitable equivalent of a claim.
Peter Gampel serves as the Managing Director for Gampel Forensic and Valuation in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Peter has extensive expertise in over 4o years of practice, including Big”4” CPA firms, in forensic accounting, business valuation, litigation support, and expert witness testimony services. For more information, please visit, www.forensicandvauation.com.